For this assignment I reviewed a podcast from Our City Podcast: Fabulous Phoenix. The direct link to this podcast is http://img671.libsyn.com/img671/8ea7355ad9cc96d2bbe09567bd33b207/454f7e9c/4701/6980/Phoenix.mp3
What was the topic of the podcast? The topic of this podcast was an overview of the city of Phoenix. It was made by a 5th grade class from Phoenix that was exploring its city.
Was the topic or point obvious? Yes, the topic was very obvious. There was a host who explained what they were going to be doing at the very beginning of the podcast. I knew right away what to expect.
Do you think a written script was used? Yes, I am almost positive that a written script was used. Because the students are in 5th grade, it makes sense to allow them to use a script in order to have an impressive final podcast. Also, using a script ensured that all of the main and important points were covered for each topic.
Did the speakers sound fluent or did they stumble around? The speakers sounded fluent for the most part. They occasionally stumbled over a word or two, but for the most part they sounded very prepared. Some of their mistakes may have simply been due to nervousness.
Were there problems in the editing (music too loud or distracting? Dead air?): The editing was satisfactory in my opinion. The students all came through loud and clear without being so loud that it became unclear what they were saying. Also, there were transitional sounds when they switched topics. These sounds served to break up the monotony of the podcast. They were used very effectively. Also, there was no background music while the students were speaking, which allowed the listener to focus on the content rather than background noises. Finally, there was no dead air time.
Did the podcast hold your attention? This podcast held my attention for about 60-70% of the time. The fact that each new topic was presented by a different speaker helped to hold my attention. The transitional noises aided in this, too. However, because there were no visuals I found it hard to pay attention the entire time. Also, because it was obvious they were reading from a script, sometimes their intonation made me a little drowsy. It could become very sing-songy at times. Overall, I would be happy if this was the final project of my 5th grade class.
WHAT ELEMENTS ARE NECESSARY FOR A GOOD PODCAST?
*no dead air
*appropriate use of music, background noises, etc.
*organization
*balance between script and spontaneous speech
*good expression in the speaker's (s') voice(s)